GMAT Critical Reasoning: every question type, with solved examples.
What each CR question asks, how to attack it, and 13 solved questions with every option explained.
Critical Reasoning in the GMAT Focus Edition
The Verbal Reasoning section has 23 questions in 45 minutes, split between Critical Reasoning and Reading Comprehension. Sentence Correction is no longer tested, so CR now carries more weight. Expect roughly 9 to 11 CR questions.
GMAT CR question types and how to approach them
| Type | What it asks | How to approach it |
|---|---|---|
| Weaken | Which option most undermines the conclusion | Find the gap between evidence and conclusion; look for an alternative cause or a broken assumption |
| Strengthen | Which option most supports the conclusion | Close the gap: rule out alternatives or confirm the assumption |
| Assumption | What the argument must take for granted | Negate each option: if the argument collapses, it is the assumption |
| Paradox | What explains two facts that seem to conflict | The answer must make both facts true together |
| Flaw | What is wrong with the reasoning | Name the error: correlation as cause, part for whole, ignoring alternatives |
| Evaluate | What would help assess the argument | Pick the question whose answer would strengthen it one way and weaken it the other |
| Inference | What must be true, or is best supported | Stay close to the text; avoid options that go beyond it |
| Role of a statement | What function a sentence plays | Find the conclusion first, then label each part |
| Parallel | Which argument has the same structure or flaw | Reduce both to a pattern, such as "all A are B, so all B are A" |
Common wrong-answer patterns
- Out of scope: relevant topic, irrelevant to the conclusion
- Wrong direction: strengthens when you need to weaken
- Too weak: true but hardly affects the argument
- Too strong: an inference that goes further than the text allows
- Restating a premise instead of filling the gap
Timing for GMAT Critical Reasoning
Aim for about 1 minute 45 seconds per CR question. Read the question stem first so you know whether you are weakening, strengthening or finding an assumption before you read the argument.
13 solved GMAT Critical Reasoning questions
A city introduced a congestion charge on cars entering its centre during peak hours. In the year after the charge began, the number of cars entering the centre at peak hours fell by 18 percent. The city's transport office concluded that the charge was responsible for the fall. Which of the following, if true, most seriously weakens the transport office's conclusion?
- Some drivers who stopped entering the centre at peak hours began entering it just before peak hours began.
- In the same year, a new metro line opened that connects the city's largest suburbs directly to the centre.
- The revenue from the congestion charge was higher than the transport office had predicted at the outset.
- Several nearby cities that did not introduce a charge saw the number of cars on their roads rise that year.
- Most of the drivers who continued to enter the centre at peak hours were travelling for business purposes.
Show answer and explanation
Answer: B. A new metro line offers an alternative cause for the fall (B). (A) is consistent with the charge working. (C) is irrelevant to cause. (D) slightly strengthens the conclusion. (E) describes who still drives, not why others stopped.
Manager: Our customer satisfaction scores rose sharply after we began offering a free gift with every order over a certain amount. So the gift has made our customers happier with our service. The manager's reasoning is most vulnerable to criticism on the grounds that it fails to consider the possibility that:
- competitors may begin offering similar gifts, reducing the advantage the company now enjoys.
- some customers who received the free gift did not particularly value the item they received.
- the cost of offering the free gift may be greater than the extra revenue it has generated.
- customers who place large orders tend to give higher satisfaction scores regardless of any gift.
- customer satisfaction scores can be affected by factors other than the quality of service.
Show answer and explanation
Answer: D. If the gift encouraged larger orders, and large-order customers already score higher, the rise may reflect who is ordering, not the gift's effect on happiness (D). (E) is too general to identify the flaw. (B) does not undermine an average effect. (C) and (A) concern cost and competition, not the causal claim.
Most species of songbird that nest in the region's forests have declined in number over the past twenty years. The decline has been steepest among species that spend the winter in tropical regions far to the south. Species that remain in the region all year have declined only slightly. Which of the following hypotheses is most strongly supported by the information above?
- Conditions encountered away from the region's forests have contributed to the decline of some species.
- Loss of forest habitat in the region is the main cause of the decline of all songbird species there.
- Songbirds that remain in the region all year are better adapted to cold weather than migrating birds.
- The number of songbirds in tropical regions has risen as northern populations have declined.
- Within twenty years, migratory songbirds will no longer nest in the region's forests at all.
Show answer and explanation
Answer: A. If the steepest declines are among species that leave, something outside the region likely plays a role (A). (B) would affect resident species as well, and 'main cause of all' is too strong. (C) is a different claim. (D) and (E) go beyond the evidence.
Several hospitals have adopted a checklist that surgical teams must complete before each operation. Studies show that hospitals using the checklist have lower rates of surgical complications than hospitals that do not. Health officials therefore plan to require the checklist in all hospitals. Which of the following would be most useful to evaluate whether the officials' plan is likely to reduce complications?
- Whether the adopting hospitals differed in other ways that affect complication rates.
- Whether the checklist takes more than a few minutes to complete before each operation begins.
- Whether surgeons in hospitals without the checklist would prefer not to be required to use it.
- Whether the checklist was designed by surgeons or by hospital administrators and officials.
- Whether the rate of complications in all hospitals has fallen over the past decade or so.
Show answer and explanation
Answer: A. If adopting hospitals were already better in other respects, the checklist may not be the cause (A). (B) and (C) concern burden or attitude, not effectiveness. (D) is irrelevant. (E) does not compare adopters with non-adopters.
Some critics argue that the town's new library is a waste of money, since most residents now read on their phones. But the library's visitor numbers have been higher than projected in every month since it opened. In the argument above, the statement about visitor numbers plays which of the following roles?
- It is a qualification that limits the scope of the conclusion drawn by the critics.
- It is the conclusion that the argument as a whole is designed to establish for the reader.
- It is evidence offered in support of the critics' view that residents now read on phones.
- It is a premise that the critics themselves accept as the basis of their own objection.
- It is offered as evidence against the critics' claim that the library is a waste of money.
Show answer and explanation
Answer: E. The visitor numbers are cited to challenge the critics' claim (E). (B) is wrong: the implied conclusion is that the library is not a waste. (C) and (D) misstate whose side it supports. (A) misdescribes its role.
A company found that employees who work from home two days a week report higher job satisfaction than those who work in the office every day. The company plans to allow all employees to work from home two days a week in order to raise overall job satisfaction. The plan assumes which of the following?
- Employees who work from home two days a week are more productive than those in the office.
- Employees now in the office daily would also become more satisfied working from home.
- The company's office space could be reduced if more employees worked from home.
- Job satisfaction is the most important factor in whether employees stay with a company.
- Most employees who now work in the office every day have asked to work from home.
Show answer and explanation
Answer: B. The plan works only if the satisfaction gain transfers to those not currently working from home; if those who chose home working were already happier types, it may not (B). (A), (C) and (D) are not needed. (E) is not required: they need not have asked.
Farmers in a region have begun planting a new variety of wheat that resists a common fungus. Although the new variety produces slightly less grain per plant than the old one, the region's total wheat output rose last season. Which of the following, if true, best explains how total output rose despite the lower yield per plant?
- Last season the fungus destroyed much of the old variety's crop where it was still grown.
- The new variety requires less water than the old variety, which reduces the cost of irrigation.
- Grain from the new variety sells at a slightly higher price than grain from the old variety.
- Some farmers in the region continued to plant the old variety because they distrusted the new one.
- The old variety had been grown in the region for several decades before the new one appeared.
Show answer and explanation
Answer: A. If the fungus destroys much of the old crop, a resistant plant can yield more in total even if each healthy plant yields less (A). (B) and (C) concern cost and price, not output. (D) would, if anything, lower output. (E) is irrelevant.
Editorial: The government claims that its new training programme has reduced unemployment among young people. But the programme has trained only a few thousand people, while youth unemployment has fallen by several hundred thousand. The programme cannot therefore have contributed to the fall. The editorial's reasoning is flawed because it:
- fails to establish that youth unemployment would have fallen even without any training programme.
- relies on figures about the programme that come from the government whose claim it is disputing.
- treats the programme's inability to explain all of the fall as proof it explained none.
- assumes that the people trained by the programme were all unemployed before they joined it.
- ignores the possibility that the programme may reduce unemployment more in future years.
Show answer and explanation
Answer: C. A small programme can still contribute to a large fall; the editorial confuses 'not the whole cause' with 'no cause' (C). (B) does not identify a logical flaw. (A) and (D) are not what the argument depends on. (E) is beside the point of the past contribution.
Researchers found that children who eat breakfast every day score higher on school tests than children who do not. They concluded that eating breakfast improves children's ability to concentrate in class. Which of the following, if true, would most strengthen the researchers' conclusion?
- Teachers report that children who skip breakfast are more often absent from school.
- Children who eat breakfast every day are also more likely to get enough sleep than other children.
- Children who do not eat breakfast are more likely to come from households with lower incomes.
- Some children who eat breakfast every day still score below the average on school tests.
- Among similar children, those then given breakfast at school scored higher than before.
Show answer and explanation
Answer: E. A before-and-after change among similar children, once breakfast is provided, isolates breakfast as the cause (E). (B) and (C) suggest alternative causes. (D) does not undermine an average. (A) introduces absence, a different explanation.
Software firm: Our new security update reduced the number of successful attacks on client systems by 40 percent. Clients who did not install the update saw no change in the number of attacks. Which of the following, if true, most seriously weakens the firm's claim that its update caused the reduction?
- Competing firms released similar security updates for their own clients at about the same time.
- The number of attempted attacks on all clients rose slightly during the period after the update.
- Some clients who installed the update still experienced at least one successful attack that year.
- The update was more expensive than previous updates that the firm had offered its clients.
- Clients who installed the update had mostly also just hired dedicated security staff.
Show answer and explanation
Answer: E. If the update was installed mainly by clients who also added security staff, the staff could explain the reduction (E). (B) makes the result more impressive. (C) does not undermine a 40 percent reduction. (D) and (A) are irrelevant to cause.
A museum began charging for admission on weekdays while keeping weekends free. Weekday attendance fell by a third, but total monthly attendance changed very little. Which of the following, if true, most helps to explain the result described above?
- The museum added a new exhibition during the period when weekday charges began.
- The admission charge on weekdays was lower than at most other museums in the city.
- Many visitors who used to come on weekdays began coming on weekends instead.
- Weekday visitors had previously stayed longer in the museum than weekend visitors.
- School groups, which usually visit on weekdays, were exempt from the new charge.
Show answer and explanation
Answer: C. If weekday visitors shifted to free weekends, weekday numbers fall while the total holds (C). (B) does not explain the shift. (A) might raise attendance but does not explain the pattern. (D) is about duration. (E) would reduce the weekday fall, not explain the stable total.
To reduce littering in its parks, a city placed more rubbish bins in them. A year later, the amount of litter collected from the ground in the parks had fallen sharply. Officials concluded that the extra bins had reduced littering. Which of the following, if true, most strengthens the officials' conclusion?
- The parks with the most new bins were those that had the most litter before.
- The city also ran an anti-littering campaign on television during that year.
- The number of people visiting the parks was about the same in both years.
- Litter collected from the streets around the parks fell by a similar amount.
- Some park visitors said they had not noticed that new bins had been placed.
Show answer and explanation
Answer: C. If visitor numbers were stable, the fall in litter cannot be due to fewer visitors (C). (B) offers an alternative cause. (A) does not show the bins worked. (D) suggests a city-wide cause. (E) slightly weakens the conclusion.
Nutritionist: People who drink green tea regularly have lower rates of heart disease than those who do not. But regular green-tea drinkers in this country also tend to exercise more and smoke less. So we cannot conclude from these figures alone that green tea protects against heart disease. The nutritionist's argument proceeds by:
- offering a counterexample of a person who drinks green tea and has heart disease.
- showing that the figures about green tea and heart disease were collected in a biased way.
- arguing that green tea is harmful to people who already exercise and do not smoke.
- pointing out that other differences between the groups could account for the observed result.
- claiming that exercise and not smoking are the only causes of lower heart disease.
Show answer and explanation
Answer: D. Exercise and smoking are alternative explanations for the lower rates (D). (B) is not argued. (C) and (A) are not in the argument. (E) is far stronger than the nutritionist's claim.
GMAT Critical Reasoning: FAQs
How many Critical Reasoning questions are in the GMAT?
Usually about 9 to 11 of the 23 Verbal Reasoning questions in the Focus Edition.
Is Sentence Correction still on the GMAT?
No. The Focus Edition removed Sentence Correction; Verbal is now Critical Reasoning and Reading Comprehension only.
What is the most common GMAT CR question type?
Weaken and strengthen questions together are the most common, followed by assumption questions.
How do I get better at GMAT Critical Reasoning?
Identify the conclusion first, predict the gap, and review every wrong option to learn which trap caught you.
Is there a free GMAT Verbal practice test?
Yes. GRADFLIX GMAT Verbal Mock 1 is free with every option explained.
GMAT Verbal mocks →GMAT RC passages →
GRADFLIX is not affiliated with or endorsed by GMAC. GMAT is a registered trademark of the Graduate Management Admission Council. Written by Abhishek Leela Pandey for GRADFLIX.