The Plan That China Grew Out Of

Two scholars suggest that China did not trade its plan for a market but let a market grow around the plan, and the later strains show what that choice left behind.

Abhishek Leela Pandey18 Nov 20263 min read4 questions ↓
A red Chinese Communist Party flag in the foreground overlooking Shanghai’s modern financial district skyline at sunset, symbolising China’s transformation from communism to a global capitalist economic powerhouse.

The economist Barry Naughton, in Growing Out of the Plan, a study of Chinese reform between 1978 and 1993, advanced a claim that sits uneasily with the common picture of China as a communist state that borrowed markets. The plan, he argued, was never dismantled and then replaced. It was left in place while a market economy grew up around it, until the plan became a small part of the whole. Reform in this reading was not a transition from one system to another but an expansion that made the old system matter less.

The central device was the dual track. Under it, a producer owed the state a fixed quota of output at a fixed price, and any output above the quota could be sold at market prices. The scheme had a virtue that a sudden abolition of the plan lacked. State enterprises and the officials who ran them lost nothing they already held, and so had little reason to resist. Meanwhile every new unit of output, and every new firm, faced a market price, so that the market's share grew without any single act of liberalisation. On this view the economy worked by growing past the plan and not by defeating it.

The popular version of the story differs in emphasis. It treats the household responsibility system in farming, the Special Economic Zones established on the coast in the early 1980s, and entry to the World Trade Organization in 2001 as three acts of opening, each a step toward the market. A second scholar, Yuen Yuen Ang, suggests that the steps were less planned than this implies. In How China Escaped the Poverty Trap she describes what she calls directed improvisation, in which central leaders set broad goals and left local officials room to experiment with the means. On this view the Chinese state did not hold markets inside a machine so much as keep adjusting the machine while it ran.

Reform in this reading was not a transition from one system to another but an expansion that made the old system matter less.

Both accounts leave a question that the later history makes sharper. The dual track suited a period when the plan was large and the market small. As the market grew, the question became what the state would keep. Strategic industries, major banks and land remained under state control, and later years brought troubles, among them heavy borrowing by local governments, a property sector burdened by debt, and household consumption that is low relative to investment. The institutions that made growth possible and the institutions that now limit it are, in large part, the same ones.

Naughton's book ends in 1993, so it cannot say whether growing out of the plan led toward a conventional market economy or toward something stable and different. The scale of the outcome is not in doubt, since extreme poverty is estimated to have fallen by some 800 million people between 1978 and 2018, although some scholars dispute the poverty line used. What remains in doubt is how long a system can stay half plan and half market, and whether its prosperity depended on the half that is now under strain.

CAT VARC practice

This passage is written in the CAT style. Its 4 questions are just below, and you can take them on the real CAT exam screen.

Try the 4 questions ↓Solved CAT past papers →Daily CAT practice →

Also writing other exams? Solved XAT verbal PYQs, IPMAT verbal PYQs, CLAT English PYQs and GMAT reading, all free.

Economics & Business reading path · essay 9 of 10Next: The Paragraph That Moved The Market →

Discussion

Sign in to join the discussion.

More in Economic History

Economic History2 min

The Money That Never Had to Move

On a Pacific island, stones too heavy to carry changed owners without moving, and the habit has become a favourite parable about what money really is.

Abhishek Leela Pandey4 Qs · Medium
Macroeconomics6 min

The Paragraph That Moved The Market

A central bank governor says a few sentences about the future, and prices shift before any policy actually changes. Why does mere belief move an economy?

Abhishek Leela Pandey4 Qs · Hard
Business & Management4 min

How Great Teams Are Deliberately Built?

Businesses often chase star performers, yet enduring success belongs to teams that cultivate trust, amplify one another's strengths, and never stop learning.

Abhishek Leela Pandey4 Qs · Medium