The Pen Is Mightier Than the Sword

A saying from a nineteenth century play asks which kind of power lasts longer, and India's courts, jails and printing presses offer a mixed but instructive answer.

Abhishek Leela Pandey16 Nov 20266 min readUPSC
A bare prison cell in Mandalay with a low wooden desk, a lantern and a stack of handwritten pages lit by a barred window.

In June 1908 a Bombay court sentenced Bal Gangadhar Tilak to six years of transportation for articles in his newspaper Kesari, and he was carried to a prison in Mandalay in Burma. The Raj had removed the man, but it had no remedy for his habit of writing. In that cell he composed the Gita Rahasya, a commentary on the Bhagavad Gita that was published in Marathi in 1915 and read across the country long after the verdict was forgotten. The sentence belonged to a government that has left no monument in India, while the book is still read and cited.

The saying, in the form now familiar, comes from the play Richelieu of 1839 by Edward Bulwer, later Lord Lytton, though similar thoughts are older. Literally it compares two instruments, one that kills and one that records. Its deeper claim concerns the kind of power each holds. A sword can compel the body for as long as the swordsman is present, but a pen works on belief, and belief outlasts the presence of anyone who holds it. A sword wins a battle, and a pen decides what the battle is remembered to have meant. The claim is largely true over long periods and across large societies, but it describes a condition and not an unconditional law, because a pen is mightier only where it is free to write and safe to read.

UPSC Mains essay practice

This essay is written in the UPSC Mains style. See how the real essay papers have been set, and practise more topics.

Solved UPSC past papers →Daily UPSC practice →
Education & Knowledge reading pathFollow the education & knowledge path: 10 essays, easy to hard →

Discussion

Sign in to join the discussion.

More in Reading & Writing

Learning & Pedagogy5 min

How EdTech Forgot Teaching | The 111th Essay

How online education, CAT coaching, AI summaries, and viral learning frameworks transformed teaching into performance, attention, and endless preparation.

Abhishek Leela Pandey4 Qs · Medium
Learning & Pedagogy5 min

The Things We Teach Each Other

I learnt to teach through a fairy without wings. Years later, I understood that learning and teaching may be among our oldest human impulses.

Abhishek Leela Pandey4 Qs · Medium