The Act That Morality Praises

Some acts are good to do and not wrong to omit, and that small gap in moral theory has proved hard to fill.

Abhishek Leela Pandey19 Nov 20262 min readXAT3 questions ↓
A lone figure in a dusty street stepping back toward a doorway of a plague stricken town while others walk away, lit by a thin amber evening sun.

Supererogation is the name moral philosophers give to acts that go beyond the call of duty, acts that are praised when done and not condemned when left undone. The word entered the modern debate through J O Urmson, whose essay of 1958, Saints and Heroes, complained that the usual division of actions into the obligatory, the forbidden and the merely permitted had no room for the soldier who throws himself on a grenade or the doctor who stays on in a plague stricken town. Such acts, Urmson argued, are not duties, since nobody is blamed for declining them, yet they are not merely permitted either, since the world would be poorer without them. They seem to require a fourth category, and that is exactly where the difficulty begins.

The difficulty is that morality is ordinarily understood as a guide to what a person ought to do, and it is hard to see how an act can be better than its alternatives without being something one ought to do. If the grenade act is the best thing available, why is it not required? A utilitarian may answer that it is required whenever it does the most good, and that the fourth category is an illusion produced by the sense that duty must be bearable. A Kantian may reply, differently, that moral law binds every rational agent alike, so that a sacrifice which is personal and extraordinary belongs to character and not to law. Defenders of the category, such as David Heyd, find its value in the freedom of the gift, which an obligation would destroy. Yet this answer has a cost. If heroism is admired because it is freely given, then a society that comes to expect it has quietly turned it into a duty, and the hero who is told that anyone would have done the same has been robbed of the very quality for which the act was admired. The category may therefore be real and still fragile, kept alive only by the willingness of observers not to demand what they admire.

XAT verbal practice

This passage is written in the XAT style. Its 3 questions are just below in exam mode.

Try the 3 questions ↓Solved XAT past papers →Daily XAT practice →
Philosophy reading pathFollow the philosophy path: 10 essays, easy to hard →

Discussion

Sign in to join the discussion.

More in Ethics

Ethics3 min

The Runaway Tram That Was Never Meant to Be Polled

The trolley problem began as a footnote in an argument about abortion. Its journey into the engineering of driverless cars may have changed what it was built to ask.

Abhishek Leela Pandey3 Qs · Hard
Ethics7 min

Hachikō and the Weight of Waiting

Why does Hachikō's story still move millions? A philosophical reflection on loyalty, memory, grief, and the kind of love that outlives death itself.

Abhishek Leela Pandey4 Qs · Medium