The Mean That Is Not an Average

Aristotle placed courage between cowardice and rashness, and the middle he meant is harder to find than a point halfway between two extremes.

Abhishek Leela Pandey11 Nov 20262 min readXAT3 questions ↓
A lone figure in a plain cloak stands at the edge of a dark gorge at dawn, one foot on the rock and one lifted, with a rope bridge fading into pale mist ahead.

Courage is commonly imagined as the absence of fear, and the imagining is mistaken, for a person without fear has no occasion for courage, only for luck. Aristotle, in the Nicomachean Ethics, places the virtue between two failings, cowardice, which fears what ought not to be feared or fears it too much, and rashness, which fears too little. This is often summarised as a doctrine of the mean, and it is just as often misread as advice to be moderate. The mean Aristotle has in mind is not an arithmetic average between two quantities of daring. It is a mean relative to the person and the situation, fixed by right reason, so that the same act may be courageous in one man, foolhardy in another and cowardly in a third who could have done more. A soldier who rushes an enemy position in ignorance of the danger is not braver than the one who understands it and advances all the same. He is merely less informed, and what looks like boldness is the absence of the very perception that gives courage its meaning.

The difficulty is that the measure of fit lies in a judgement that cannot be written down in advance. To say that courage is the right amount of fear about the right things at the right time sounds like an instruction, but it merely restates the problem, since the right amount is recognised only in the person who has it. Aristotle accepts this circle openly and answers it with the figure of the practically wise person, whose perception serves as the standard. A sceptic may find the answer unsatisfying, and the sceptic has a point, for a standard that is identified by the example it sets cannot settle disputes about who the example is. Yet the alternative is no easier. A rule that fixed in numbers how much risk may be taken for how much good would turn courage into arithmetic and leave no room for the judgement that a particular dawn, a particular crowd and a particular fear demand. The virtue seems to survive precisely where the rule fails, which may be a sign that it was never a rule.

XAT verbal practice

This passage is written in the XAT style. Its 3 questions are just below in exam mode.

Try the 3 questions ↓Solved XAT past papers →Daily XAT practice →
Philosophy reading pathFollow the philosophy path: 10 essays, easy to hard →

Discussion

Sign in to join the discussion.

More in Virtues & Vices

Virtues & Vices3 min

The Art of Doing Nothing: An RC Inspired by IIM Indore

In a civilisation that measures human worth through activity, doing nothing appears almost irresponsible. Yet the ability to pause, withhold action and resist the demand to remain productive may be one of the most neglected forms of wisdom.

Abhishek Leela Pandey4 Qs · Hard
Virtues & Vices2 min

The Eight Years Darwin Spent on Barnacles

A man holding the idea of the century spent eight years describing barnacles. Whether that was patience, fear or bad luck depends on which motive a historian prefers.

Abhishek Leela Pandey6 Qs · Medium
Philosophy of Mind6 min

The Phenomenology of Embarrassment

Embarrassment is not shame. It is not guilt. It is the moment the self discovers, with retroactive mortification, that it has been visible all along, and that visibility was never chosen.

Abhishek Leela Pandey4 Qs · Hard
Political Philosophy3 min

The Communist Manifesto: An RC Inspired by IIM Indore

The Manifesto was written in six weeks by two men in their twenties. It inspired revolutions on four continents. The question is not whether its argument is correct. It is why the argument works so well.

Abhishek Leela Pandey4 Qs · Hard