The Thin Line Between Difference and Disorder
ADHD is defined by behaviour and not by a biological marker, and that single fact explains why prevalence, adult onset and treatment are all still argued over.

ADHD is defined by behaviour and not by a biological marker. The fifth edition of the American Psychiatric Association's diagnostic manual, published in 2013, describes a persistent pattern of inattention, hyperactivity and impulsivity that begins before the age of twelve, appears in more than one setting and interferes with functioning. No blood test or brain scan can confirm the diagnosis in an individual. This is common in psychiatry, but it means the boundary of the condition is a decision about how much deviation counts as disorder, and such decisions can be defended only by argument.
A review by Polanczyk and colleagues in 2007 put the worldwide prevalence among children and adolescents at about five percent, and a review in 2014 found that most variation between studies came from method and not from country or decade. Diagnosed rates nevertheless differ by place and have risen in several countries. Studies in the United States and Canada, among them Morrow and colleagues in 2012, found that the youngest children in a school year were diagnosed more often than the oldest, which suggests that part of what is measured is a child's standing against classmates and not only a property of the child.
The condition is not merely a social construction. Twin studies place the heritability of ADHD traits high, often near three quarters, and the condition is linked to differences in functions such as inhibiting a response and tolerating delay, which Russell Barkley and others place at the centre of their accounts. But heritability is neither destiny nor a boundary. Height is highly heritable too, and no one defines a disorder by it. The traits appear to be spread continuously through the population, so the threshold is drawn through a continuum, and where it falls depends on consequences and not on nature alone.
Height is highly heritable too, and no one defines a disorder by it.
The adult case sharpens the dispute. The conventional view holds that ADHD begins in childhood. Yet Moffitt and colleagues, following a New Zealand birth cohort to the age of thirty eight, reported in 2015 that most adults who met the criteria had not met them as children, and a British twin study in 2016 found a similar pattern in part. Others reply that childhood assessments missed many people, girls above all. The evidence is consistent with two readings, a late onset form or an earlier form that went unseen, and it does not yet choose between them.
Findings on treatment are similarly divided. The Multimodal Treatment Study, reported in 1999, found that medication, alone or with behavioural therapy, outperformed routine community care over fourteen months, yet follow ups at three and eight years found that much of the advantage had faded. That does not show whether the symptoms are best understood as a deficit or as a variation. Advocates of neurodiversity, a term linked to Judy Singer in the late 1990s, argue for the second. The question may be wrongly posed, since a trait can be a variation and a source of impairment at once, depending on the demands placed upon it by schools and workplaces that could have been arranged otherwise.
CAT VARC practice
This passage is written in the CAT style. Its 4 questions are just below, and you can take them on the real CAT exam screen.
Also writing other exams? Solved XAT verbal PYQs, IPMAT verbal PYQs, CLAT English PYQs and GMAT reading, all free.
Discussion
Sign in to join the discussion.
More in Neurodiversity
I Thought Everyone Saw the World This Way
A reflective essay on teenage love, mathematical thinking, and why I instinctively translated people, emotions, and the world into algebra.
Sexiness Is Not a Property of the Body
Beauty can be catalogued but desire keeps slipping out of the list, which suggests that attraction lives in a relationship and not in a body.
The Forgotten Third of Our Lives
Why can't we remember our dreams? Discover how REM sleep, memory, and evolution shape the forgotten third of our lives.
What Happens When You Actually Change Your Mind: An RC Inspired by IIM Indore
Most arguments do not change minds. They change voiced positions. Genuine belief revision is neurologically different, phenomenologically distinct and far rarer than it appears.



