Bigger Is Not Always Better

From the dairy farmers of Kaira to the panchayats, the payments network and the vaccine drive, this model essay asks when size serves a purpose and when it only flatters the powerful.

Abhishek Leela Pandey11 Nov 20266 min readUPSC
A line of women farmers carrying steel milk cans walks down a village lane at dawn towards a modest collection shed, with a large factory chimney faint on the horizon.

In 1946 the milk farmers of Kaira district in Gujarat had a problem that no amount of hard work could solve. Each owned two or three buffaloes, and each depended on one private dairy, which collected their milk and set the price. They approached Sardar Patel, who advised them to organise themselves into a cooperative, and out of a few hundred litres a day in a modest union grew the brand now called Amul. The farmers were small and poor, but together they were not powerless. The story is told as a triumph of cooperation, yet it also carries a quieter lesson, that smallness and size are not opposites, and that the question worth asking is how a society should decide when to be one and when to be the other.

The saying that bigger is not always better holds, in its plain sense, that size does not guarantee quality, efficiency or fairness. A larger school, firm, city or state is not necessarily a better one, and there are many cases in which growth has made an institution slower, colder and less answerable to those it serves. In its deeper sense the saying warns against a habit of mind that treats scale as proof of merit, the habit of counting the biggest dam, the tallest statue or the largest budget as evidence of success. This essay argues that scale is a tool and not a virtue, that its worth depends on what is being done, and that a wise society matches its size to its purpose and not the other way round.

UPSC Mains essay practice

This essay is written in the UPSC Mains style. See how the real essay papers have been set, and practise more topics.

Solved UPSC past papers →Daily UPSC practice →
Economics & Business reading pathFollow the economics & business path: 10 essays, easy to hard →

Discussion

Sign in to join the discussion.

More in Business & Management

Business & Management2 min

The Razor That Was Never Given Away

Business schools teach that Gillette gave away the handle and earned from the blades. The company's own price lists suggest the story arrived later than the strategy.

GRADFLIX Editors4 Qs · Medium
Business & Management2 min

The Flaw Intel Called Rare

A professor found a division error in a Pentium chip in 1994, and a company answered with probabilities. The bill that followed was measured in hundreds of millions of dollars.

Abhishek Leela Pandey4 Qs · Medium