The Diamond That History, Law and Diplomacy Describe Differently

Who owns the Kohinoor depends on which discipline is asked. Each gives a coherent answer, and none of them silences the others.

Abhishek Leela Pandey10 Nov 20262 min readCLAT5 questions ↓
A large cut diamond rests on a velvet cushion in a dim vault, with faint reflections of a treaty parchment in its facets.

The Kohinoor, a diamond now set in a crown kept in the Tower of London, can be studied through three lenses, and each gives a different answer to the plain question of who owns it.

History offers the first lens. The stone passed between rulers by conquest and tribute across several centuries, through Mughal, Persian, Afghan and Sikh hands. After the Second Anglo Sikh War, the Treaty of Lahore of March 1849 stated in its third article that the gem was to be surrendered by the Maharaja of Lahore to the Queen of England. The signatory, Duleep Singh, was a boy of about ten, and the terms were those of a victor. The stone was presented to Queen Victoria in 1850. A historian therefore sees a transfer, and asks whether a transfer from a child under occupation deserves to be called a gift.

History offers the first lens.

Law offers the second lens. Courts decide by the rules in force when an act took place, and the treaty, however unequal, is a signed document. The 1970 UNESCO Convention on illicit trade in cultural property is not generally applied to events before it came into force. In India, a petition about the stone reached the Supreme Court in 2016, where the government's lawyer was reported to have said that the diamond had been given and not stolen. The remark drew sharp criticism, and the government later said it would continue its efforts to bring the stone home.

Diplomacy offers the third lens. British governments have said repeatedly that the stone is lawfully held, and have declined to return it, partly from a worry that one return would invite many claims on museum collections. India, Pakistan, Iran and Afghanistan have each made claims at various times. For ordinary people, however, the meaning of the stone does not depend on a court. It works as a symbol of how empire treated treasure and of how nations choose to remember.

CLAT English practice

This passage is written in the CLAT style. Its 5 questions are just below in exam mode.

Try the 5 questions ↓Solved CLAT past papers →Daily CLAT practice →
History & Civilization reading pathFollow the history & civilization path: 10 essays, easy to hard →

Discussion

Sign in to join the discussion.

More in Colonialism & Empire

Colonialism & Empire5 min

The Bengal Famine Was Not a Food Shortage

In 1943 millions starved in a province that, on much of the evidence, still held food. The economist who watched it as a child spent a career arguing that famines are not about what a country grows but about who is allowed to eat.

Abhishek Leela Pandey · Hard
Modern History5 min

The Search Before the Search

The Greenbrier Ghost helped reopen a murder case. What followed reveals a deeper truth about evidence, belief, and knowledge.

Abhishek Leela Pandey4 Qs