The Sorrow That Is Tasted

Indian theories of drama hold that an audience does not suffer the actor's grief but tastes it, and that this tasting is a third thing between stage and spectator.

Abhishek Leela Pandey16 Nov 20262 min readXAT3 questions ↓
An empty open air stage at dusk with oil lamps lit along its edge and a single actor's mask resting on a wooden stool.

Rasa, in the theory of Indian drama, names neither the feeling a character has nor the feeling a spectator brings into the hall, but a third thing that exists only in the act of watching. The Natyashastra, attributed to the sage Bharata and dated by scholars across several centuries on either side of the beginning of the common era, sets out eight such flavours, among them the erotic, the comic, the compassionate, the heroic and the terrible, and treats each as the ripened form of a lasting emotional disposition. The distinction matters because it refuses a simple answer to an old puzzle, namely why anyone should choose to sit through grief that is not their own. If the audience merely caught the actor's sorrow, the theatre would be a place of contagion, and if it merely observed that sorrow coldly, it would be a place of instruction. Neither description explains why spectators leave moved and yet unharmed.

The answer most closely associated with the Kashmiri philosopher Abhinavagupta, who wrote around the turn of the first millennium and built on earlier commentators, turns on a process usually translated as universalisation. Characters and events on the stage are not experienced as belonging to this particular man or woman, who is distant in time and place, nor as belonging to the spectator, whose own concerns have been set aside for the evening. The emotion is lifted out of the private frame in which ordinary suffering is bound to desire and fear, and so it can be savoured and not merely endured. The image Abhinavagupta's tradition prefers is that of tasting, and the metaphor is exact, since a taste is neither the food nor the eater but what occurs when the two meet.

The theory has its critics and its limits. A sceptic may say that calling an emotion universal merely renames the problem, since a feeling stripped of every particular attachment may no longer be recognisable as grief at all. A defender may reply that the stripped feeling is exactly what separates art from life, where sorrow is always someone's and always demands something. Whether the delight of rasa is a refinement of emotion or a release from it remains a question the tradition itself keeps open, and the later addition of a ninth flavour, shanta or calm, which Abhinavagupta and others defended, suggests that detachment, and not only feeling, was thought to be among the things the stage could offer.

XAT verbal practice

This passage is written in the XAT style. Its 3 questions are just below in exam mode.

Try the 3 questions ↓Solved XAT past papers →Daily XAT practice →
Philosophy reading pathFollow the philosophy path: 10 essays, easy to hard →

Discussion

Sign in to join the discussion.

More in Aesthetics

Philosophy of Mind6 min

The Phenomenology of Embarrassment

Embarrassment is not shame. It is not guilt. It is the moment the self discovers, with retroactive mortification, that it has been visible all along, and that visibility was never chosen.

Abhishek Leela Pandey4 Qs · Hard
Political Philosophy3 min

The Communist Manifesto: An RC Inspired by IIM Indore

The Manifesto was written in six weeks by two men in their twenties. It inspired revolutions on four continents. The question is not whether its argument is correct. It is why the argument works so well.

Abhishek Leela Pandey4 Qs · Hard