The Pen That Was Said to Make People Smile
A pen held in the teeth was once said to make cartoons funnier. When seventeen laboratories tried it again, the effect nearly vanished, and the argument moved to why.

In 1988 a study reported that people who held a pen between their teeth, which forces a smile, rated cartoons as funnier than people who held it with their lips. Many textbooks concluded that smiling makes people happier. In 2016 seventeen laboratories repeated the procedure with nearly 1,900 participants and found an average difference close to zero. Some researchers therefore concluded that the original result was probably a fluke.
Discussion
Sign in to join the discussion.
More in Mood & Emotion
The Forgotten Third of Our Lives
Why can't we remember our dreams? Discover how REM sleep, memory, and evolution shape the forgotten third of our lives.
I Thought Everyone Saw the World This Way
A reflective essay on teenage love, mathematical thinking, and why I instinctively translated people, emotions, and the world into algebra.
What Happens When You Actually Change Your Mind: An RC Inspired by IIM Indore
Most arguments do not change minds. They change voiced positions. Genuine belief revision is neurologically different, phenomenologically distinct and far rarer than it appears.
The Zipper You Don't Understand
Most people are certain they understand how a zipper works, until asked to explain it. The same gap shows up in political conviction.



