The Machine That Pressed Ahead While Its Warnings Piled Up

A radiation machine that removed an older layer of protection kept reporting errors that its operators had learned to ignore. The lesson drawn from the overdoses is still contested.

Abhishek Leela Pandey8 Nov 20262 min readGMAT4 questions ↓
A white radiation therapy machine stands in a dim treatment room while a technician in the control room watches a green error message on a monitor.

In July 1985 at a cancer clinic in Hamilton, Ontario, a Therac 25 radiation machine displayed an error and reported that no dose had been delivered. The operator pressed the key to proceed, as operators routinely did when malfunctions were frequent, and the display repeated the message five times. The patient is estimated to have received a dose many times the intended one.

In 1983 the manufacturer, Atomic Energy of Canada Limited, had produced a fault tree for the machine that excluded software as a source of failure. The earlier Therac 20 had carried independent mechanical interlocks, and the new model relied more heavily on software to do the same protective work, reusing code from earlier machines.

When the Hamilton clinic reported its patient, the manufacturer suggested that a microswitch might have failed momentarily, a fault it could not reproduce. Investigators who later wrote about the case consider a software error more likely.

Investigators who later wrote about the case consider a software error more likely.

In 1986 two further overdoses occurred at a clinic in Tyler, Texas, where operators again met cryptic error messages and again pressed on, because pauses had become an ordinary part of the working day.

Regulators in Canada asked that pauses be turned into treatment suspensions, and the manufacturer instead reduced the permitted number of retries from five to three. By 1987, after six overdoses between June 1985 and January 1987, the machine was recalled for design changes that included hardware safeguards against software errors. Engineers still debate whether the lesson is that software is dangerous or that any single layer of protection is.

GMAT reading practice

This passage is written in the GMAT style. Its 4 questions are just below, and you can take them on a GMAT-style exam screen.

Try the 4 questions ↓Daily GMAT practice →
Science reading pathFollow the science path: 10 essays, easy to hard →

Discussion

Sign in to join the discussion.

More in Engineering

Engineering1 min

The Bridge That Resonance Did Not Break

The collapse of the Tacoma Narrows Bridge is taught as a lesson in resonance. Two engineers argued in 1991 that the lesson was wrong.

Abhishek Leela Pandey2 Qs · Medium
Mathematics7 min

Would a Fourth Dimensional Being Be a God?

A thought experiment in higher dimensions asks whether what looks like a miracle might simply be reality viewed from a geometry we cannot perceive.

Abhishek Leela Pandey4 Qs · Hard