The Fine That Gave Parents Permission to Be Late
A small fine was meant to make parents collect their children on time. It did the opposite, and it went on doing so after it was withdrawn.

In January 1998, researchers working with ten private day care centres in Haifa began a modest experiment. They wanted to learn whether a small penalty would reduce late collection of children. At six of the centres they introduced a fine of ten shekels per child for any parent who arrived more than ten minutes after the four o'clock closing time. Four centres kept the old arrangement and served as a comparison.
The result was the reverse of the expectation. Within a few weeks the number of late arrivals at the fined centres began to rise, and after three or four weeks it settled at nearly double the starting level, while the comparison centres showed no such change.
The result was the reverse of the expectation.
At the beginning of the seventeenth week the fine was withdrawn. A simple view of incentives would predict a return to the old pattern. Instead, lateness stayed higher than at the comparison centres. The parents behaved as though a different arrangement had been established, and removing the charge did not restore the earlier one.
The authors offered two explanations that the data could not separate. Under the first, the fine told parents something new about how seriously the staff took lateness, perhaps that it was not serious. Under the second, a price replaced an obligation, so that parents who had felt guilty began to feel they were simply buying extra time. They also noted that a larger fine might have worked, so the study does not show that penalties fail, only that a small one can change what a rule means.
Which reading is correct remains unknown, and the two suggest very different remedies for the same crowded gate at four o'clock.
GMAT reading practice
This passage is written in the GMAT style. Its 4 questions are just below, and you can take them on a GMAT-style exam screen.
Discussion
Sign in to join the discussion.
More in Behavioural Economics
The Supersonic Jet and the Money Already Spent
Continuing a failing project looks irrational until the cost of stopping is counted.
The Cobra Effect Was a Rat Problem
The most quoted warning about bad incentives concerns snakes in Delhi that nobody has been able to find. The rats of Hanoi, which did exist, made the same point and were forgotten.
Losing Feels Worse Than Winning Feels Good: An RC Inspired by IIM Indore
Kahneman and Tversky found that losses tend to weigh more heavily than equal gains. How much more is still debated, and economics has not been the same since.
The Paragraph That Moved The Market
A central bank governor says a few sentences about the future, and prices shift before any policy actually changes. Why does mere belief move an economy?



