The Optimist in Hiding and the Century That Answered Him

A hunted man wrote the most confident book about human improvement in March 1794. Malthus, two world wars and the Indian Constitution have each answered it since, and none has closed the argument.

Abhishek Leela Pandey26 Oct 20266 min readUPSC
A candle burning in a small bare attic room in Paris where a man writes at a table, with soldiers' lanterns passing in the street below.

In March 1794, in a small room at the Paris house of a woman named Madame Vernet, a man with a warrant out for his arrest wrote a book about the future happiness of humankind. He was the Marquis de Condorcet, a mathematician and a deputy of the Revolution, and the authorities he had served now called him a traitor. He had opposed the execution of Louis XVI and had voted against the Jacobin constitution of 1793. Within weeks he would leave his hiding place, be arrested at an inn and die in prison two days later, before any tribunal could hear him. The book was his Sketch for a Historical Picture of the Progress of the Human Mind, and it remains one of the strangest optimistic documents ever written.

The Sketch divides human history into ten epochs, from the first small societies to the French Revolution and then into a tenth that had not yet happened. Condorcet admitted that he had good evidence for some of the stages and was only speculating about others. His central claim was that the laws of nature are constant, so that the growth of knowledge follows a pattern that needs no divine hand. Reason, spreading through education and printing, would free people from religious and political domination. Inequality between nations and within them would shrink. He expected the equality of women to be recognised, and he had already helped lead the French Society of the Friends of the Blacks, an abolitionist group.

Discussion

Sign in to join the discussion.

More in Progress & Modernity

Modern History5 min

The Search Before the Search

The Greenbrier Ghost helped reopen a murder case. What followed reveals a deeper truth about evidence, belief, and knowledge.

Abhishek Leela Pandey4 Qs
Ancient History5 min

The Grain Before the Word

The world's first writing wasn't poetry or prayer. It was an invoice for barley, and that changes what writing's origin actually tells us.

Abhishek Leela Pandey4 Qs