Is Humanity Really Moving Forward?

To say that history has progressed is to claim a direction, and the claim looks different in knowledge, in welfare and in morals.

Abhishek Leela Pandey11 Nov 20263 min read4 questions ↓
A minimalist conceptual illustration of a crumbling stone staircase ascending towards a glowing golden horizon, symbolising human progress, civilisation and the uncertainty of historical advancement.

To say that a society has progressed is to make a claim about direction, and a claim about direction differs from a claim about speed, comfort or wealth. The idea itself is younger than it feels. The historian J. B. Bury argued in The Idea of Progress, published in 1920, that the belief that civilisation has moved, is moving and will continue to move in a desirable direction became a guiding principle of thought only in the modern period, and that the ancient world, which tended to picture history as decline or as cycle, had managed without it.

The difficulty begins with the word desirable. Progress in knowledge is the easiest kind to defend, since a theorem proved or a disease understood does not ordinarily become unproved or misunderstood. Progress in welfare is harder, because it requires a measure, and every measure, whether life expectancy, income or literacy, leaves something out. Progress in morals is hardest of all, because the standard by which a later age is judged better is supplied by that later age. A critic may fairly say that the claim to have improved is always made by those who have arrived, and that those who were left behind have rarely been consulted.

Defenders reply that the measures, though partial, converge. Steven Pinker's Enlightenment Now, published in 2018, gathers long series on health, violence and income to argue that the broad direction of human life since the eighteenth century has been upward. The reply has force, since it is difficult to dismiss a fall in child mortality as a matter of perspective. Yet the case rests on the choice of series and of starting points, and the choice of a ruler is itself an argument. Critics, among them the philosopher John Gray, have maintained that gains in knowledge do not carry gains in wisdom with them, and that the same techniques that lengthen lives can also lengthen wars.

Yet the case rests on the choice of series and of starting points, and the choice of a ruler is itself an argument.

What both camps tend to share is an assumption that progress is one thing that can be affirmed or denied as a whole. It may be more useful to treat it as a set of separate claims, each with its own evidence and its own cost. A society can advance in medicine while it regresses in trust, and gain in material security while it loses the means to notice what it has lost. To ask whether history has a direction then becomes a question about which domains one has in mind, and about who is doing the asking.

The practical consequence is modest but real. If progress is a bundle of separable claims, then the defence of any one of them cannot borrow credit from the others, and a gain in one area gives no licence to ignore a loss in another. The belief that history is on one's side has often been used to excuse what is done on its behalf. Whether a general theory of progress can survive such disaggregation, or whether it was only ever a story the modern age told about itself, remains an open question.

CAT VARC practice

This passage is written in the CAT style. Its 4 questions are just below, and you can take them on the real CAT exam screen.

Try the 4 questions ↓Solved CAT past papers →Daily CAT practice →

Also writing other exams? Solved XAT verbal PYQs, IPMAT verbal PYQs, CLAT English PYQs and GMAT reading, all free.

History & Civilization reading pathFollow the history & civilization path: 10 essays, easy to hard →

Discussion

Sign in to join the discussion.

More in Progress & Modernity

Progress & Modernity6 min

The Optimist in Hiding and the Century That Answered Him

A hunted man wrote the most confident book about human improvement in March 1794. Malthus, two world wars and the Indian Constitution have each answered it since, and none has closed the argument.

Abhishek Leela Pandey · Hard
Modern History5 min

The Search Before the Search

The Greenbrier Ghost helped reopen a murder case. What followed reveals a deeper truth about evidence, belief, and knowledge.

Abhishek Leela Pandey4 Qs